Why Amazon May Decide Not to Post Your Book Review

So…here’s my tangent today and I’d like to share it with all of you.

Yesterday I noticed a post on my Facebook feed about a petition to prevent Amazon from arbitrarily deciding not to post book reviews based upon their belief that the reviewer might know the author.  What this means is that if you post a book review and  Amazon thinks you know the author personally, they may refuse to publish your book review.

Screen Shot 2015-07-10 at 12.25.11 PM

I find this really disturbing, and here’s why:  what criteria is Amazon using to determine whether I know the author?  Is it because I’m giving a really great review?  Is it because I follow their Facebook Author Page?  Maybe I’ve interacted with the author a few times through that page.  Or maybe, just maybe, I’m Facebook “friends” with an author.  The problem is that none of those contacts mean that I actually know an author.  It simply means that, for whatever reason, the  author and I have made some sort of acquaintance.  He or she doesn’t know me from a stranger on the street, and would be very right to be frightened if I were to knock on their door.

Even still.  What if I do know the author?  Does my knowing the author preclude my ability to give a fair and honest review?  And how is knowing an author (and my ability to leave a fair review) any different than being an avid fan of an author?  I’d argue that I’d have a bit harder time giving a bad review to an author whose work I simply love than I would one that I knew.  Just because I know someone doesn’t mean that I think he’s brilliant.

Here’s the truth:  whether I know you or not, I’m not likely to give you a scathing review unless I truly hate what you’ve written.  And, I won’t give you a raving review unless what you’ve written is truly spectacular in my opinion.  Very few authors get a full 5-star rating from me, and very few authors get a single 1-star rating.

Now, here’s a real problem as I see it:  Social media has allowed authors to have direct contact with their readers in a way they never have before.  Facebook and Twitter have allowed readers to easily reach out to their favorite authors and, in many cases, those authors are kind enough to respond.  Some authors are very active on their author pages and, while they don’t know any of their followers, they interact prolifically with them all.  This is a really good thing all around.  It’s good marketing for the author, but it also makes the reader feel appreciated.  If Amazon continues with this decision to refuse to publish a review by an author’s “friend,” this can only hurt the wonderful interactions authors have been able to foster with their readers.

So, what can you do?  If you think Amazon’s decision is wrong – or at least arbitrary – you can sign the petition asking them to rethink this decision by following this link.

Whether you agree with me or not, reviews are important to authors.  Even bad reviews are good and important.  The next time you pick up a book, take a moment to leave an honest review on one of the many outlets available (B&N, Amazon, Goodreads, etc).  The author will appreciate it.

For now, I’ll leave you with a bit of humor.  Someday I hope to have a whacko fan like this. Or maybe not.  It didn’t work out so well for Paul Sheldon.

10 responses to “Why Amazon May Decide Not to Post Your Book Review”

  1. Kristie Higgins Avatar
    Kristie Higgins

    Reblogged this on Chivalry.


  2. I think many writers have mixed feelings about Amazon. Will definitely tweet your article. Best of luck to you, Cathie!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks! Luckily this hasn’t happened to me as an author…yet but I can see it happening to me as a reader/reviewer. I talk to too many published authors on a regular basis…


  3. Sooo much luck and happiness to you..I hope that the book proves to be bang on and helps in changing lives..I’ll do my little part in your big success by buying it! Yay! The book looks really interesting..looking forward to read it! Btw your grandmother is so amazing and she handled so much.. May her soul rest in Peace! And lastly I loved the title of the book! *_*!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so very much!!! I hope you enjoy it when you read it!!


  4. I am so sorry..I wanted to post this comment in your blog “the edge of nowhere”.. I don’t know how this happened..really sorry!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hahah! It’s totally okay. I knew what you meant. :). Have an awesome day.


  5. Excellent! I’m glad people are getting involved in this. Saying that you can’t have any online contact is ludicrous in this day and age. Thanks so much for posting this.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you – and I obviously agree with you! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: